
I Geo-Economics & ChokepointsMiddle East and North Africa
Kuwaiti jurist says Gulf treaties should shield investors from missile damage
- Institution
- Kuwait University (Arab News opinion page)
- Author
- Bashayer Al-Majed
- Country · language
- Kuwait · English
- Affiliation
- Academic, op-ed in a Saudi newspaper
Summary
Bashayer Al-Majed, a law professor at Kuwait University, wrote in Arab News on 19 November about the legal position of foreign investors under missile attack. In her view, an investor suffering war damage is not simply at the mercy of politics. Bilateral and regional investment treaties offer a written framework of protection. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait have been part of that system for more than 40 years.
Most treaties place a duty of full protection and security on the host state. Al-Majed recalls the first treaty case at the World Bank's arbitration centre. The 1990 AAPL v Sri Lanka award did not treat this standard as strict liability. The tribunal held that the diligence expected of a reasonable government was sufficient. In the 1997 AMT v Zaire case, Zairean soldiers looted an American investment and the government took no action. The tribunal ordered Zaire to pay 9 million dollars in compensation. War-loss clauses, by contrast, require only equal treatment. They do not hold the host state liable for damage inflicted by an enemy.
The author argues that Saudi Arabia is in practice showing that diligence. Its air defences have shot down missile after missile. Riyadh airport reopened within 10 days of being hit. The Unified Agreement for the Investment of Arab Capital, signed in 1980, gives an Arab investor the right to sue another Arab state. In 2013 a tribunal relying on that agreement ordered Libya to pay about 935 million dollars to Kuwait's Al-Kharafi & Sons. A Cairo court later annulled the award. Al-Majed proposes two concrete steps for the Gulf. Model treaties should include an explicit war-loss clause. Every attack on civilian infrastructure should be documented to an evidentiary standard.
Blind spot
The piece does not say who fired the missiles or which facilities were hit on which dates. It does not show from the texts whether Saudi and Kuwaiti treaties contain war-loss clauses. The Libya case shows an arbitral award can fall in a national court, but the author does not weigh that risk for the Gulf. The claim of Saudi diligence is not tested against an opposing view; the piece appeared in a Saudi newspaper.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
In the Kuwaiti jurist's reading, war is shifting Gulf investment risk from physical damage to legal uncertainty. Treaties expect diligence from the host state, not results. Damage caused by an enemy attack mostly stays with the investor. The Gulf's ability to attract capital therefore hinges on the success of its air defences and the clarity of its treaty texts. The most likely path is for Gulf states to update their model treaties slowly, one by one.
Likely effects
- Direct investmentNegative1–6 months
Because enemy damage cannot be pinned on the host state, investors price war risk themselves. New capital coming to the Gulf will demand higher returns.
- Legal recoveryNegative6 months+
The annulment in Cairo of the roughly 935 million dollar award against Libya leaves the collection of arbitral winnings dependent on national courts.
- Saudi ArabiaPositiveWeeks
Examples such as Riyadh airport reopening within 10 days give the Saudi government strong evidence for a reasonable-diligence defence.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Slow updating55%
Gulf states add war-loss clauses to new treaties while existing treaties stay as they are.
Watch: Saudi Arabia or Kuwait publishing a new model bilateral investment treaty text
- 2Wave of disputes30%
Damaged investors go to arbitration and the diligence standard is tested in the Gulf for the first time.
Watch: A new case registered at the World Bank's arbitration centre against a Gulf state over war damage
- 3Law takes a back seat15%
The attacks stop, disputes are settled through political bargaining and treaty reform drops off the agenda.
Watch: A lasting ceasefire in missile attacks on the Gulf
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Original publication: arabnews.com · 19 November 2026
This page summarises the institution's view and does not reflect the view of Talay Insight. No direct quotation is used.